Differences Between Diesel Straight Boom and Electric Straight Boom

In many fields that require aerial work, such as construction, maintenance and installation, straight boom aerial work platforms are commonly used equipment. However, there are two types of power for straight boom aerial work platforms on the market: diesel and electric, which makes many buyers who don't know much about the industry tangled. Next, we will analyze the differences between diesel and electric power for boom lifts, so that you can learn more about them when purchasing and make the right choice.
Translation of "Energy Supply and Power Source"

The diesel straight-arm truck uses a diesel engine as its core power source. It generates mechanical energy by burning diesel to provide power for various actions of the equipment, such as the lifting and retracting of the boom and the movement of the platform. This power mode makes the diesel straight-arm truck powerful and able to adapt to various complex working environments. The supply of diesel straight-arm trucks is relatively convenient and can be easily obtained at most gas stations, which means that the diesel straight-arm truck equipment can continue to operate for a long time without worrying about sudden energy interruptions. It is especially suitable for use in large outdoor projects that are far away from power sources and take a long time.

The electric straight-arm truck relies on electric drive to achieve this, and its power system is usually composed of batteries and electric motors. Batteries store electrical energy, and electric motors convert electrical energy into mechanical energy to drive the operation of the equipment. With the continuous advancement of battery technology, the battery life and charging efficiency of electric straight-arm trucks have been significantly improved. There are various charging methods. Conventional charging piles can be used for slow charging, and fast charging technology can be used in some qualified places to greatly shorten the charging time. However, compared with diesel telescopic boom trucks, electric telescopic boom trucks still have some limitations in terms of endurance. The continuous operation time after a single charge will be relatively shorter. It is more suitable for use in scenarios with a stable power supply, short operation time and high frequency of use.

Translation of "Application Scenarios"

With its powerful power and high climbing ability, diesel straight-arm trucks have significant advantages in complex outdoor environments. In construction, diesel straight-arm trucks can easily cope with complex ground conditions, muddy and rugged terrain, and can stably drive to the designated location and carry out operations. In some remote areas, for the construction of some infrastructure, installation and maintenance of large outdoor billboards, etc., due to the distance from the city’s power supply network, the diesel straight-arm truck’s own power source advantage can be fully utilized, and it can independently complete high-altitude operation tasks without relying on external power supplies.

Although the lifting speed of electric telescopic boom trucks may be slightly slower than that of diesel telescopic boom trucks, with the continuous development of electronic control technology, its lifting speed is also gradually increasing, and it can achieve precise speed control. In terms of carrying capacity, electric telescopic boom trucks can also meet the requirements of most conventional aerial operations. For some tasks with high precision requirements, such as precise replacement of glass curtain walls, electric telescopic boom trucks can more accurately position the working platform to the required position through precise electronic control systems to ensure smooth operation.

Performance characteristics

Diesel straight-arm trucks are generally equipped with a high-power hydraulic system that can provide a high hydraulic flow and achieve a faster lifting speed. When it is necessary to quickly lift the operator or cargo to a specified height, the diesel straight-arm truck can respond more quickly, greatly improving the efficiency of the work. At the same time, due to the strong power of the diesel engine, the diesel straight-arm truck performs well in terms of carrying capacity, and can easily carry heavier tools and materials, meeting the high-intensity operation requirements such as large-scale equipment installation and heavy cargo handling.

Although the lifting speed of the electric straight-arm truck may be slightly slower than that of the diesel straight-arm truck, with the continuous development of electronic control technology, its lifting speed is also gradually increasing, and precise speed control can be achieved. In terms of carrying capacity, the electric straight-arm truck can also meet the requirements of most conventional high-altitude operations. For some tasks with high precision requirements, such as precise replacement of glass curtain walls, the electric arm truck can more accurately position the working platform to the required position through a precise electronic control system to ensure the smooth progress of the operation.

Procurement and Operations

The purchase cost of diesel straight-arm trucks is relatively low, mainly because the power system technology is mature and the production scale is large, making the overall price of the vehicle more affordable. However, in the subsequent operation process, the fuel consumption cost of diesel straight-arm trucks is high, especially when the oil price fluctuates greatly, the uncertainty of operating costs increases. In addition, the high maintenance cost is also further increasing the burden of operation.

The purchase cost of electric straight-arm trucks is relatively high, mainly due to the high cost of its batteries. However, with the continuous advancement of battery technology and the large-scale production of batteries, the cost of batteries is gradually decreasing, and the price of electric straight-arm trucks is gradually becoming reasonable. In terms of operating costs, electric straight-arm trucks have obvious advantages. Their electricity consumption cost is much lower than the fuel consumption cost of diesel straight-arm trucks, and the maintenance cost is low, and the comprehensive operating cost is relatively low. For users who have been using straight-arm aerial work platforms for a long time, the advantages of electric straight-arm trucks in operating costs are more prominent, which can save a lot of money for enterprises.

There are significant differences between diesel telescopic boom trucks and electric telescopic boom trucks in many aspects. When choosing, you should consider various factors such as the operating environment, operating requirements, cost budget, and environmental protection requirements. I hope that the above introduction to the differences between diesel telescopic boom trucks and electric telescopic boom trucks will help you make a clearer choice.